Poll: Is Namibia becoming increasingly militarised?

+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: Namibia is being militarised

  1. #1
    juikk's Avatar
    juikk is offline Senior Member Awards:
    Discussion Ender
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Windhoek, Namibia, Namibia
    Posts
    466
    Blog Entries
    5

    Default Namibia is being militarised

    Good Sheebeners, I saw the below letter in the Namibian dated 30 Apr 2010 and found it worth deliberating on. is there any reason to worry as per writer? what do the Shebeeners think?

    30.04.10
    The Real Reason For Militarisation

    THE editor, Gwen Lister, in her weekly column ‘Political Perspective’ (April 23 2010) expressed her concern about the militarisation of our society. We fully concur with her position and would like to further the discussion of this crucial issue.

    It is true that Namibia is at peace with its neighbours, but in our view this increased military budget is really aimed at ‘internal enemies’. It is about time for Namibians to wake up to what is really going on around them.

    The Finance Minister seemed clearly unable to motivate this increasing militarisation or perhaps that was deliberate to hide the true intentions. However, when she spoke about ‘our enemies,’ we should understand that she really meant those who are not Swapo and those who are not part of the elite.

    In the short term, the Namibian military is being prepared for a Zimbabwe-type situation in this country. Given Swapo’s long history of political intolerance, if the political opposition (RDP?) were to defeat the ruling party in the next general elections, it is highly likely that the Namibian military would launch a campaign of intimidation at grassroots level and keep Swapo in power.

    This might sound farfetched at this time but are we prepared to take the risk? We should stop fooling ourselves with the myth of Namibian exceptionalism. It happened in Zimbabwe and it could definitively happen here. In the long term, the Namibian military would be a tool to suppress an uprising by the working class. With the austerity measures implemented by the Swapo government, the only route open to the elite is the repression of the people.

    This is the real explanation for the ever-increasing budgets of both the military and the police. The Swapo government’s structural adjustment policies mean high unemployment, high water and electricity prices, wage and salary freezes, downscaling of education and health, low salaries for teachers, nurses and other public sector workers, etc. This translates into a constant decline in living standards for the majority of the people.

    Sooner or later, the people would no longer be fooled by populist nationalism and will rise up. That is why the ruling class needs a strong state – a big army and police – to prepare themselves for the eventual uprisings. In the case of Namibia, there is a significant intersection of tribe and social class, i.e. a convergence exists between Oshiwambo-speakers and the ruling class.

    In this sense, we wish to say to that insightful intellectual, Alexactus Kaure, that the Marxist analysis remains relevant in Namibia. In fact, the re-militarisation of Namibia is an example of the ‘Africanisation’ of politics here, although we disagree that this is only confined to this continent. The brave resistance of the red-shirts in Thailand against the military regime there is a case in point. It is also true that the logic of tribalism only leads to increasing social fragmentation and disunity, but ultimately it is all about economic power and greed.

    This is why the right-wing of Swapo is the most dangerous political force in this country because that tendency uses tribalism as a smokescreen to get to the economic resources. And it is usually middle class leaders that promote tribalism for their selfish interests.

    The elite are only focused on looting the country. Tribalism is just the surface reality. We agree with the interesting Alfredo Hengari that Nahas Angula is a politician with depth amongst many shallows, but Angula’s tragedy is that Swapo is in office but not in power. That is why the office of the prime minister and parliament in general are ineffective in terms of the important issues of the country.

    The limitations of this government are a reflection of the huge economic compromises that Swapo made at the negotiations for political independence. The petty-bourgeois nationalism only brought us a hollow political independence and no economic emancipation. In fact, the colonial regime used to have social-democratic policies, but the Swapo government secretly agreed to austerity measures which result in permanent and ever-worsening pauperisation of the people. The populist nationalism of Swapo is just the empty rhetoric of a greedy elite.

    This is why the militarisation of Namibia will continue. The peoples of Thailand, Greece, Kyrgyzstan, Cuba, Venezuela and Bolivia are fighting back, why can’t we? We should start an anti-militarisation campaign now. T. Itembu and K. Basson Katutura
    Letter copied over from : the Namibian: The Real Reason For Militarisation

  2. #2
    Kurt Mauser is offline Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Windhoek
    Posts
    30

    Default Namibia is being militarised

    Juikk,

    To add to the worry, we currently have one of the highest per capita police numbers in the world, and the force has just been given the green light for a 2000 member increase......

    All good and well if the aim is to curb crime, which it sadly is not. The BULK of the force are illiterate plan comrades, and members of the SFF. The SFF is swapos version of the SS.

    EVERY time I needed assistance from the Police, they failed completely to show up. I also dont see foot patrols by them to deter house breakings etc. And why did Windhoek have to establish the city police if our relatively large police force were actually doing police business??

    I have some VERY interesting statistics at home regarding this topic. I will try and post tonight. Then people can draw their own conclusions......

  3. #3
    Comrade007's Avatar
    Comrade007 is offline Senior Member Awards:
    Posting Award
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Windhoek
    Posts
    533

    Default Re: Namibia is being militarised

    I have absolutely no doubt in my mind that there is a trend towards increasing militarisation in our Republic. Actually, it has been militarised from the time well before Independence, and continues to be since Independence. The thread, the mind-set of the liberation war continues to inform and dominate the political discourse within SWAPO and the SWAPO elite to this day. Its main proponents are Nujoma and his cabal, stuck as they are in the past and ruling the country from behind the scenes.

    Their argument is as simple as it is politically effective for the pursuit and tight grip on political power: SWAPO "won" the war for freedom and Independence; SWAPO=Namibia; Namibia = SWAPO ; SWAPO "owns" Namibia; SWAPO determines who is Namibian, and who is not; SWAPO is the "guardian" of the liberation.

    Put simply, maybe simplistically: It is not we the people who truly "own" our nation, and who are the guardians of our nation's soul. It is not the Consitution and the values and principles it enshrines and seeks to uphold that makes Namibia. The guardians of our nation is not the Supreme court, but the court of SWAPO.

    There is also no doubt in my mind that there are democratic, enlightened and progressive, tolerant and open, forces in SWAPO, but they do not hold sway and their voices remain subsumed. When they are expected to speak up they keep quiet. I think our current President, Hifikepunye Pohamba is one of them, but he is nominally in charge, and an administrator of sorts of Nujoma's whims and wishes, and those if his cabal.

    It has been said before in this forum in another thread: Namibia is an open, tolerant, democratic society to the extent that this does not challenge SWAPO's dominance and grip on power in any way whatsoever.

    The recent elections have shown quite clearly the willingness of the establishment to further cement the grip on all the institutions of the nation, on all the resources and the political discourse. In the end, this may well be ours - Namibia's - undoing in the medium- to long-term: The fact that the space for meaningful, internal political renewal is being curtailed little by little, with every election, and the increasing militarisation of our society.

    SWAPO has for some time now been establishing the outriders of its first ring of defence against "unpatriotic, foreign, neo-imperialist, neo-colonialist forces", i.e. those Namibians who challenge SWAPO's hegemony and its increasingly strangling grip on our nation's political and economic soul. This trend is set to continue.

    We have not reached the end-game, as Zimbabwe has, and won't any time soon. But given current developments this is clearly visible on the horizon. Will SWAPO listen and learn? I doubt it. Can it listen learn? I doubt that as well. For political leadership on our Continent - in Namibia - has and is primarily concerned with the pursuit and maintenance of political and economic power right here, right now - whatever the political, social and economic costs. The nation is simply not more important than the party, and the party looks after its elite, its members. Simple as that.

    It has always been, and it will be so until a new generation of enlightened, truly democratic and competent leadership takes over the mantle of power and focusses its energy and limited resources on the pursuit and establishment of a meaningful Namibian social contract that provides for internal political renewal and truly free contest of the power over the State; that provides for a true Namibian identity apart from that of SWAPO; that allows for the people to truly determine the fate of the nation.

    Call me a cynic, or a reactionary element, or whatever. Before you do, consider this: How many individuals born in Namibia that are not overtly married to SWAPO; that do not overtly show and peldge their political loyalty and allegiance to SWAPO have received official recognition for their contribution to the social, economic, civic and political development of our nation since Independence? A handful - maybe. And how many of them are buried at the Freedom Acre? Think about that. Says a lot, doesn't it?

    I can list the nations that recognise and reward the efforts of - for example - opposition politicians for their contribution to free political discourse; of journalists and writers who challenge the Government, the elite and speak their mind; of human rights activists; of ordinary people who speak out where they see something that to them is patently wrong; of individuals who do not pledge allegiance to the status quo but challenge it and fundamentally question it as well.

    If you are thinking of contributing to the development of our nation in whatever way, keep in mind that your efforts may well not be recognised and rewarded officially by the Government unless and until you are "cleansed" and "drink from the well of SWAPO"; until you have "become SWAPO". It is for SWPAO to determine who the heroes and heroines of pour natinon are, and how they are recognised.

    There is simply no space for a Namibian-ness apart from SWAPO.

    Sad, but true, and it shows the true face of the current political "leadership", and it is a sign of just how far we will still have to walk to call ours a truly tolerant, open, democratic and civilised society.
    Last edited by Comrade007; 4th May 2010 at 07:31 PM.
    "Nothing is complete and thus nothing is exempt from criticism." - James Luther Adams:

  4. #4
    Kurt Mauser is offline Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Windhoek
    Posts
    30

    Default Re: Namibia is being militarised

    Comrade 007,

    In my opinion, yours is a true reflection on the situation. It mirrors my sentiments 100%.

    Look at the defense budget. About 2 BILLION dollars. In real terms (taking inflation into consideration) it has remained roughly at this level over the past 20 years.

    Do the maths. In todays value, 40 BILLION ( That is, Fourty Thousand Million !!) dollars to "defend" us against what??

    The average SME can create a permanent job opportunity for LESS THAN 200 000 DOLLARS INVESTED !! ( In my own business, I created 8 jobs for only 1 million dollars invested. The average job thus created pays N$ 5000 per month.)

    Devide 40 billion by 200 000........TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND direct jobs could have been created over the past 20 years if the money was GIVEN AWAY to SME's.....And this number does not even reflect the number of "downstream" jobs created as a result. Studies show that for every new direct job created, THREE downstream jobs are also created ( Taxi drivers, shop owners, stall owners etc)

    Also consider that this 40 billion need not be "given" to SME's - They could ask for it to be repayed, but at 0% interest. That way even more jobs could have been created......

    Also consider the boost in income govt would have, with an additional 500 000 people paying VAT on everything they buy, income tax, company tax...

    This means, sans the NDF, we could have COMPLETELY eradicated unemployment in Namibia !!

    Unfortunately, our swapo leadership lacks the necesary vision for this. As long as they have new "Imperialist German" luxury cars to accomodate their ever increasing waistlines, they are happy.

  5. #5
    Kurt Mauser is offline Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Windhoek
    Posts
    30

    Default Re: Namibia is being militarised

    As promised, some statistics on the Insane level of militarisation in Namibia.

    We should keep in mind that uniformed police is also part of governments "armed" forces. What is more, the police is required to deal with "internal threats". Keeping that in mind, look at the following statistics (taken from the Landbou Weekblad, 9 April 2010, )

    Statistics for the ratio of police / inhabitants for a few nations:

    England & Wales: 268 people / Police Member
    South Africa: 322 people / Police Member
    United States: 392 people / Police Member
    Canada: 492 people / Police Member
    New Zealand: 537 people/ Police Member
    Finland: 647 people / police Member

    NAMIBIA: 125 PEOPLE / POLICE MEMBER !!

    If the NDF numbers are added to the Police and Special Field Force numbers, we have ONE ARMED, UNIFORMED GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEE (under SWAPO CONTROL) FOR EVERY 58 CIVILIANS IN NAMIBIA !!!!

    Then also keep in mind that recently noises were once again made in Parliament to further limit the sale of firearms to civillians....

    WHY ??

    What is the long term plan ? A UNARMED civilian population is defenseless against government tirrany. To claim that reduced civilian firearm ownership will reduce crime, is either incredibly stupid or an eyeblind. Over the last decade or so, LESS THAN 5% OF MURDERS IN NAMIBIA WERE COMMITTED WITH FIREARMS, and those that were committed using guns were virtually EXCLUSIVELY committed with unlicenced firearms. Reduing (or banning even) of legally owned guns would:

    a) Leave Criminals with a free reign, knowing victems are unable to defend themselves

    b) Leave us all open to the Tyranny of Government.

    I think these 2 issues ( Increased numbers of State Armed Forces and Civillian Dis-Armament) go hand in hand, since it is all part of a sinister, broader scheme by the Swapo Government !!!!

    To finish off, I would like to post a few examples of what happens after civilian dis-armament for those who do not believe me:


    In 1929, the Soviet Union established gun control.. From 1929 to 1953,
    about 20 million dissidents, unable to defend themselves, were rounded
    up and exterminated.
    ——————————
    In 1911, Turkey established gun control. From 1915 to 1917, 1.5 million
    Armenians, unable to defend themselves, were rounded up and exterminated.
    ——————————
    Germany established gun control in 1938 and from 1939 to 1945, a total
    of 13 million Jews and others who were unable to defend themselves were
    rounded up and exterminated.
    ——————————
    China established gun control in 1935. From 1948 to 1952, 20 million
    political dissidents, unable to defend themselves, were rounded up and
    exterminated
    ——————————
    Guatemala established gun control in 1964. From 1964 to 1981, 100,000
    Mayan Indians, unable to defend themselves, were rounded up and
    exterminated.
    ——————————
    Uganda established gun control in 1970. From 1971 to 1979, 300,000
    Christians, unable to defend themselves, were rounded up and
    exterminated
    ——————————
    Cambodia established gun control in 1956. From 1975 to 1977, one million
    educated people, unable to defend themselves, were rounded up and
    exterminated.
    —————————–
    Defenseless people rounded up and exterminated in the 20th Century because of gun control: 56 million.

    I rest my case.....

  6. #6
    juikk's Avatar
    juikk is offline Senior Member Awards:
    Discussion Ender
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Windhoek, Namibia, Namibia
    Posts
    466
    Blog Entries
    5

    Default Re: Namibia is being militarised

    Wow, thx for stats kurt....we are indeed in serious trouble...how to mobilise channge before we are extinct is the question?

  7. #7
    tjommie is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Location
    Windhoek
    Posts
    27

    Default Re: Namibia is being militarised

    want to spin another view on this...

    anyone consider that voters need to get paid? The police service and military is a quick way of providing 'a job' to people. It does not pay well, but it offer some form of income to people...?

    it is a completely wrong way of 'job creation'. I heard the other day that at independence there were 16 parastatels and now we have 96...

    what the hell for? Someone said to me, 'brothers need to get paid'...

  8. #8
    Comrade007's Avatar
    Comrade007 is offline Senior Member Awards:
    Posting Award
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Windhoek
    Posts
    533

    Default Re: Namibia is being militarised

    Quote Originally Posted by tjommie View Post
    Someone said to me, 'brothers need to get paid'...
    Very useful perspective, Tjommie. It has that feel to it, doesn't it? Employment creation in the public and security services is the oldest trick in town and one that governments all over the world resort to reflexively. But it's not gonig to get our nation forward in the long run. It's all consumption spending, and no real investment in the human capital. The taxes that now go to apying for these peeps could/should be spent on other things. But of course try and tell that to someone who is hungry and has to feed the kids. Not easy, admittedly, but I'm just not sure giving them all a job in the security services is a good idea either.
    "Nothing is complete and thus nothing is exempt from criticism." - James Luther Adams:

  9. #9
    Dude's Avatar
    Dude is offline Senior Member Awards:
    Downloads
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Posts
    100

    Default Re: Namibia is being militarised

    We got to balance things here. It's better to have some of these peeps in uniform and off the streets even if they don't do much and are not productive in the economy except spending for food, clothing, services. But if it becomes too many then there's no money for investment spending. I think Government knows about this and they are trying their best under the circumstances.

  10. #10
    Kurt Mauser is offline Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Windhoek
    Posts
    30

    Default Re: Namibia is being militarised

    If the money was spend on INVESTMENT rather than the military to begin with, nobody would sit around looking for a job.

    Employing 30 or 40 or even 50 thousand people in the armed forces is going to do little for the 600 000 or so unemployed left......

    Face the truth. This is an insurance policy for swapo for one day when they loose the elections. ( or if they cannot manipulate the results in their favour. Take your pick)

+ Reply to Thread

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may edit your posts
  •